"Most people need the comfort of generalities," he continued. "They want to say only the correct things. They prefer conventions. They hide their specificity."
I know I hide. I hide everyday. I appear stable and unwavering. Underneath that calm cool exterior is a deep dark pool of emotion covered in white capped waves. I keep it buried not allowing the waves to crash over the edges and onto the surface of my being. I try to keep things simple on the surface. I hide the specifics. I do it to avoid complications, to avoid unnecessary questions.
"But some conventions are important don't you think? They're reassuring," I argued.
"You're right. Some conventions are necessary. They are deeply felt."
"But you think most aren't."
"No. Most are filling."
"You mean filler."
"Yes, filler. We avoid being precise or specific because we are lazy, or scared, or indifferent. Every day we say to someone 'How are you?' but we really don't want the details."
I am not lazy or indifferent. I am scared. Scared, that if I unbottle the specifics that the people around me will truly begin to believe that I am crazy. Or even worse, they will start to fire questions in my direction. This would then require that I either perfect the art of dodging or attempt to explain myself. Neither are particularly appealing to me.
**********
Of course, he was right. After all, intimacy would be diluted if expressed too readily. Even with Paolo, I often felt myself coasting on the surface, relying on physical instead of emotional closeness.
Guilty as charged. I have done this in the past. I, like so many others, have relied on physical contact to replace emotional closeness. My most recent offense in this department is G. For over a year I hid. I hid my emotion behind a wall. I detached from the situation. But then one day the dam burst and I was carried away in the flood. The waters have calmed considerably and I like to think that we have both the physical and emotional closeness now.
Was it self-preservation, dishonesty, lack of courage? I tried to imagine a life in which every conversation was a revolt against triteness. All that unfettered frustration, euphoria, nostalgia, sullenness, and anger suddenly loose in the room.
Imagine the fatigue! It was a wonder, I thought, that anyone ever speaks from the heart. Most occasions call for a defiant shallowness. More impersonal, maybe, but more sensible too.
Yes, it is self preservation and lack of courage in my case. I stick to the generalities because it is easier. Because if I get specific I open myself up to hurt. Because it is draining. I do try to be specific when it is necessary. Especially when I am looking deep into his eyes, or when trusted friends ask if I am alright, or when I have to ask difficult questions, or when I have to support those in need. I am personal when it is sensible to do so, but a vast majority of the time I wrap myself in the comfort of generalities.
j.
Italicized portions from The Letter Opener by Kyo Maclear